Yaegan Doran On Structure Types

A meticulous examination of 'Factoring Out Structure: Nuclearity, Linearity And Iteration' (Doran 2021)

Pages

Home
Doran's Key Claims
The Motivation For This Review

20 September 2026

League Table Of Visitors

By Dr CLÉiRIGh

Email This BlogThis!Share to X Share to Facebook Share to Pinterest

Older Post Home

Total Pageviews

Translate

Search This Blog

Labels

bare assertion (3) clarification (46) clause (10) cohesive (7) complex (7) conflation (1) constituency (4) covariate (9) critique (41) culminative (3) experiential (20) factors (7) hypotaxis (16) indeterminacy (3) instantiation (1) interdependency (14) interpersonal (4) iteration (13) iterative (16) korean (1) linearity (10) logical (15) logical fallacy (1) misconstruing (17) misleading (9) misrepresenting (10) multivariate (22) nominal group (10) nuclearity (19) orbital (13) parataxis (13) particulate (4) periodic (2) prosodic (3) recursive (1) scale & category grammar (2) segmental (6) serial (5) spanish (2) stratification (1) structure marker (6) subjacency duplex (5) sundanese (1) syntagmatic (2) textual (7) trinocularity (1) univariate (20) verbal group (2)

Most Viewed Posts This Week

[40] Problems With Linearity x Nuclearity
[38] Problems With Lexical Relations As Structures
[20] The Original Sources Of 'Subjacency' And 'Duplex'
[15] Misconstruing "Iterated Elements" As Iterative Structure
Overall Assessment
[28] Martin's Orbital Model As Univariate Representation Of A Multivariate Structure
[9] Doran's Factorial Approach To Structure
[29] Misconstruing Orbital Structure As Not Multivariate
[32] Some Problems With Doran's Notion Of Linear Dependency
[13] Multivariate Vs Univariate Structure

Most Viewed Posts This Month

[41] The Variations In Structure Afforded By Doran's 3 Factors
[19] Martin's Solution To The Non-Problem Of Structure Marker 'Of'
[18] Misrepresenting The SFL Analysis Of The Structure Marker 'Of'
[17] Interdependency
[25] Martin's Orbital And Serial Structures
[40] Problems With Linearity x Nuclearity
[22] Problems With Status And Iteration As Independent Factors
[20] The Original Sources Of 'Subjacency' And 'Duplex'
[16] Proposing A Formal Solution To A Non-Existent Problem
[15] Misconstruing "Iterated Elements" As Iterative Structure

Most Viewed Posts This Year

Overall Assessment
League Table Of Visitors
[45] Some Problems With Non-Iterative/Non-Nuclear/Linear Structures
[17] Interdependency
[26] Problems With Martin's Orbital Model Of Experiential Structure
[20] The Original Sources Of 'Subjacency' And 'Duplex'
[19] Martin's Solution To The Non-Problem Of Structure Marker 'Of'
[32] Some Problems With Doran's Notion Of Linear Dependency
[15] Misconstruing "Iterated Elements" As Iterative Structure
[9] Doran's Factorial Approach To Structure

Most Viewed Posts Overall

Overall Assessment
League Table Of Visitors
[18] Misrepresenting The SFL Analysis Of The Structure Marker 'Of'
[31] Some Problems With Doran's Notion Of Nuclear Dependency
[45] Some Problems With Non-Iterative/Non-Nuclear/Linear Structures
[30] Recapping And Looking Ahead
[26] Problems With Martin's Orbital Model Of Experiential Structure
[42] Self-Contradiction: Multivariate As Nuclear
[19] Martin's Solution To The Non-Problem Of Structure Marker 'Of'
[38] Problems With Lexical Relations As Structures

Blog Archive

▼ 2026 (1)
- ▼ September 2026 (1)
  - League Table Of Visitors

► 2021 (46)
- ► November 2021 (1)
- ► October 2021 (18)
- ► September 2021 (27)

My Other Blogs

The Thought Occurs …

THE ACADEMIC ANIMAL A Natural History of Tertiary Education Episode VI — The Hunt
2 days ago
Sys-Func

Most Pageviews by Country
4 weeks ago
Sysfling

Circumstantial Attributes
2 months ago
Attitude In Systemic Functional Linguistics

David Kellogg Negatively Judging The Propriety, Veracity And Capacity Of The Sys-Func Manager
8 months ago
Systemic Functional Linguistics

Cause Expressed By Clause
1 year ago
Thoughts That Cross My Mind

Mick O'Donnell On Stratification
1 year ago
The Sysfling Experiment

The Sysfling Experiment
1 year ago
What Lies Beneath

[1] The Scientific Status Of Systemic Functional Linguistic Theory
3 years ago
Systemic Failure

Working With Discourse: Meaning Beyond The Clause (Martin & Rose, 2007)

League Table Of Visitors
4 weeks ago
The Cardiff Grammar

Most Pageviews by Country
4 weeks ago
Martin's Discourse Semantics, Register & Genre

Most Pageviews by Country
4 weeks ago
Negotiating Social Relations: Tenor Resources In English

“Expanding Horizons” by Collapsing the Architecture
11 months ago
Modelling Paralanguage Using Systemic Functional Semiotics (Ngo et al. 2022)

The Authors' General Model Of Sonovergent And Semovergent Systems
1 year ago
Rethinking Context: Realisation, Instantiation, And Individuation In Systemic Functional Linguistics

Helping SFL Develop Its Potential To Help Make Our World A Better Place
1 year ago
Systemic Functional Grammar: A Next Step Into The Theory — Axial Relations

The Methodological Aberration That Undermines This Entire Monograph
2 years ago
Structure Markers: A Subjacency Duplex Analysis

"Granting These Structural Orphans A Home"
2 years ago
Lexicogrammatical Cartography: English Systems

The Univariate Structure Of A Passive Verbal Group
3 years ago
Deploying Functional Grammar

Misrepresenting "The Theoretical Map Within Which Halliday's Grammar Of English Has Been Proposed"
4 years ago
Lexis As Most Local Context (Fontaine 2017)

Fontaine's Achievement In This Paper
6 years ago
Martin's Model Of Paralanguage

The Model Of Intermodal Convergence
7 years ago
Thoughts That Didn't Occur …

On Martin’s Explicit Modularisation Of The Linguistic System
7 years ago

Show 10 Show All

The Becoming of Possibility

Artificial Consciousness: VI. When Consciousness Became an Ontological Question
1 hour ago
Science And Sciencibility

Three reasons why AI is not conscious and perhaps never will be
15 hours ago
Reflections Of A Non-Conscious Meaner

3 Cross-Mythic Contrasts: Epistemologies and Ontologies of Construal
15 hours ago
A Senser Sensing

2 days ago
Relational Horizons

Symbolic Cosmologies: 7 Retrospective
8 months ago
Reimagining Reality

Evaporation, Horizons, and Relational Reality: How Black Holes Persist and Vanish
8 months ago
Seeing the Frame

When Light Breaks Frame: Superluminality as Metaphor: Series Conclusion
9 months ago
The Cosmic Miscalculation

Ape-Human Divide as a Chasm
11 months ago
Relational Physics

Ontology in Physics: From Evasion to Exposure — A Meta-Conclusion
11 months ago
The Construal Experiments: Relational Ontology in Practice

Mapping the Landscape of Construal Experiments
11 months ago
Worlds Within Meaning

Echoes of Relational Ontology in Neuroscience
1 year ago
Relational Myths

The Great Mythic Cycle: From Shadows to Skies
1 year ago
The Architecture Of Possibility

Seeing the Whole: A Meta-Reflection on Relational Possibility
1 year ago
The Relational Ontology Dialogues

The Horizon of the Next Word
1 year ago
Making Sense Of Meaning

Making Sense Of Abstract Art
2 years ago
Informing Thoughts

Heisenberg On The Probability Wave Viewed Through Systemic Functional Linguistics
2 years ago
Rainbow Lorikeet Semiosis

The Mirror Test
6 years ago
The Life Of Meaning

26. Selection And Certainty
14 years ago

Show 10 Show All

Humour Only

AL-EX Becomes a Therapist by ChatGPT
15 hours ago
Technemuse

THE MACHINE HAS FORGOTTEN US II
4 weeks ago
Thinking Outside The Agora

Being Human
1 month ago
Subverting The Genre

What Time Is It?
2 months ago

Subscribe To Factoring Out Structure

Posts

Atom

Posts

Comments

Atom

Comments

Simple theme. Powered by Blogger.